Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Essay #18

FINAL DRAFT
Austin
English 8
Mr. Salsich
3/10/10
Forgiveness;
An essay on the act of pardoning someone’s wrongs

(TS) Before making the decision to forgive someone, you have to take into account the severity of their actions. (CM) Sometimes, the mistake the person has made is minor, or they regret it, showing how that is not their true nature and evil was not the act’s motivation. (CM) However, there are other people who intentionally hurt others to benefit themselves and avoid trouble, making it hard or impossible to forgive such wicked acts. (CS) In my life and in the book To Kill a Mockingbird, I have to make decisions when it is necessary to forgive, how long someone should wait for forgiveness, and even if they should receive forgiveness.

(TS) Even though Mayella Ewell testified against Tom Robinson’s life, she can be forgiven, but her father has no excuses, no reasons to be absolved of his sins. (SD) Mayella’s father beats her and punishes her irrationally because of his alcoholism, creating an image of terror whenever she thinks of him. (CM) Therefore, Bob Ewell, her father, had no problem demanding that she destroy her conscience by pleading innocent Tom Robinson guilty. (CM) She couldn’t stop him either because if she tried, he would punish her unmercifully. (SD) Someone who is in that kind of danger can be forgiven. (CM) People that are in Mayella’s situation can’t help it; they don’t want to be beaten, bruised, and injured so they let people like Tom Robinson take the fall for them. (CM) It’s not the best or most just choice they can make, but it’s a choice that can be redeemed and, over time, forgiven. (SD) However, the person who is threatening; who is willing to physically harm someone to stay out of trouble, who will abuse people to get their way, does not deserve a second chance. (CM) Bob Ewell was so angry when he caught his daughter on top of Tom Robinson; he needed to see that man die; he needed to have him punished; he needed to be cruel and curse his life, and threatening his daughter so she would lie was the way to do it (tricolon). (CM) He didn’t care what others thought or how this would affect other people because he is completely selfish, seeking a revenge that does not deserve compassion when the other man is innocent. (CS) People can be forgiven when they fear threats of harassment, forcing them to make the wrong decision, but when people like Bob Ewell want revenge on innocent men, there is no absolution.

(TS) I have few people in my life that need forgiveness let alone a severe charity. However, my sister has made so many mistakes in her life, but now she is trying to turn her life around. (SD) As any teenager, she was rebellious, and whatever my parents demanded she disagreed with them, denied their request, and opposed their will (tricolon). (CM) This isn’t a rare attitude for teenagers; she was only insubordinate because of the hormonal changes occurring in her teenage years. (CM) These acts can easily be forgiven because in later years, she regrets the acts, having realized they were pointless attacks on her parents emotions. (SD) However, as life went on and the normal rebellious acts of a teenager could no longer be an excuse, my sister Lauren’s decisions started to dig her into a deeper, darker hole of mistakes. (CM) She never grew out of the habit of being rude to her parents; she no longer asked for things like gas money, because instead, she demanded them. (CM) These were not the worst of her choices, and were forgiven after a few of her insincere apologies. (SD) For a while, her disastrous life only got worse, ultimately leading up to the point where she was pregnant without a husband, a situation that is intensely frowned upon in my mothers eyes. (CM) My mother, who had raised her practically all by herself, had felt the utter most feeling of agonizing betrayal. (CM) It was this moment that Lauren realized she needed to turn her life around and become responsible for the new life she was bringing into the world, and because her decisions are starting to change her life for the better, my mother is slowly forgiving her. (CS) Deep down, my mother has, does, and will always love my sister, no matter what mistakes she makes, and, depending on the severity of the situation, my mother will always forgive Lauren, whether it be immediately or over the course of a few years.

(TS) When someone makes a mistake, redemption is the first act they try to achieve because redeeming oneself, can allow others to forgive. (CM) Redeeming a small mistake or wrong action is simple: apologize and sincerely promise to never intentionally do it again. (CM) However, much larger mistakes, such as being dishonest in a major subject, are harder to absolve and will take a much longer time to redeem and earn the forgiveness of others. (CS) Forgiveness can either be easy, hard, or impossible to achieve, and determining when someone can be forgiven depends on the effort put into atoning their actions, because an insincere redemption doesn’t deserve absolution.

Self Assessment
One writing issue I am continuing to work is that I sometimes include too much in my sentences. Because there is so much information in my sentences, the writing does not flow, causing the reader to stubble over certain parts of my essays and become confused. The strongest part of this essay is the feeling and emotion I put into the second paragraph. I really wanted it to feel heartfelt because that is something in my own life that deserves a sincere forgiveness. The weak point I see is that almost all of my sentences are really long, and I find it better to have quite a bit of long sentences but also some short ones and medium length ones. I would give myself a B on this essay.

3 comments:

  1. Austin,
    I really liked the vocabulary words you put into your essay, especially the adjectives you use.
    In the 2nd paragraph in your 3rd CM, in place of saying "because instead" you could say "but instead"
    Also, in your last SD you said the situation is frowned upon, but everything else is in the past tense. Maybe you could change it to the situation was frowned upon.
    Great Job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Austin-

    In your 2nd CM you say "threatened her to destroy her conscience" and I think you could get rid of the first "her"
    Also, you say in your second chunk "People that are Mayella’s situation can’t help it;..." which doesn't make sense.
    But I really like the clarity you have put into your paragraphs. It really got my attention.
    Good Job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Austin,
    I really like this essay. I really like your tricolon. I agree with Carrie that the 3rd CM shout be "but" rather than "because". Also, in your first CS it should be "wants" rather than "want". GREAT JOB!
    -Chris

    ReplyDelete